If you are a plaintiff’s attorney who routinely deals with clients’ medical and other liens, you understand the financial strain it can place on your practice. Lien resolution delays can hold up settlement/judgment distributions for months, extending the time for lawyers to collect their fees.
The scenario is frustratingly familiar: You have finally secured a favorable settlement, or settlement, years after intaking the case, but now face further delays to identify and resolve your client’s outstanding liens. Lien resolutions can easily add incremental payment delays of 4-7 months, sometimes even longer.
In personal injury cases, medical, Medicare and workers’ compensation liens are an all-too-common issue when plaintiffs receive medical treatment or other benefits during the pendency of a litigation. Unfortunately, lien negotiations and verifications routinely extend the payment timeline far beyond a settlement/judgment. What should be the culmination of successful litigation instead becomes the beginning of another drawn-out administrative hurdle that can further strain law firm operations and client relationships.
The Three-Layered Challenge of Medical Lien Resolution
1. Private Provider Liens: The Negotiation Marathon
Negotiating liens requires precision to ensure that terms are fair and reasonable and represent the actual cost of the benefits provided, all the while increasing the costs of litigation and reducing the client’s award. With multiple collateral parties now involved, it can further delay distribution, impacting the cash flow of the client and law firm.
Private healthcare providers often bill at "chargemaster" rates that can be 3-4 times reasonable value. The challenge for attorneys is demonstrating that a $50,000 hospital bill for emergency treatment, as an example, may have a reasonable value of $15,000-$20,000 based on Medicare rates and regional standards. This negotiation process typically requires:
Each provider operates independently, creating a complex web of individual negotiations that must be coordinated and resolved before final distribution can occur.
2. Medicare Complications: Government Bureaucracy at Its Peak
Plaintiffs on Medicare create another layer of complexity in awaiting distribution, as Medicare law dictates that medical costs associated with an injury be reimbursed before the settlement/judgment funds are distributed. For the law firm, this involves providing documentation, negotiating with plan administrators, and complying with regulatory deadlines and guidelines.
Law firms are often plagued by prolonged waiting periods for approvals and calculations, impacting operating cash flows as delays finalizing settlements/judgments create a drag on the timing of distributions.
The Medicare Secondary Payer Act creates a labyrinthine process that includes:
Consider a slip-and-fall settlement involving a 67-year-old plaintiff. A $400,000 settlement might appear straightforward until Medicare's conditional payment calculation reveals $47,000 in related medical expenses. The final resolution can require months of back-and-forth documentation, appeals, and negotiations—during which the attorney's earned fees remained inaccessible.
3. Workers' Compensation: The Double-System Dilemma
Workers' compensation liens grant the insurer the right to be reimbursed from settlement/judgment proceeds. For the law firm, this creates additional time and resources to comply with these requirements, and oftentimes the distribution is held up until all legal and procedural hurdles are met.
When workplace injuries result in third-party liability claims, attorneys must navigate two distinct legal systems simultaneously. The workers' compensation carrier has already paid medical expenses and disability benefits, creating a lien against any third-party recovery. This scenario requires:
The complexity multiplies when multiple medical providers, Medicare, and workers' compensation all have claims against the same settlement/judgment proceeds.
The Economics of Effective Lien Negotiation
Successful lien resolutions require sophisticated understanding of medical billing practices and strategic negotiation approaches:
1. Reasonable Value Analysis
Healthcare billing often reflects "chargemaster" rates that significantly exceed reasonable value for services provided. Effective lien negotiation requires:
2. Negotiation Leverage Factors
Several key factors influence lien negotiation outcomes:
3. Procedural Complications That Create Delays
Documentation Requirements
Comprehensive lien resolution requires extensive documentation including:
4. Multi-Party Coordination Challenges
Complex cases often involve multiple lien holders with competing interests:
Coordinating resolution with all parties requires careful timing and communication to avoid delays from individual lien holder scheduling or procedural requirements.
5. Administrative Processing Delays
Even after negotiated resolutions are reached, administrative processing can create additional delays:
The Financial Impact of Lien Delays on Law Firms
Lien resolution delays can negatively impact the duration of a distribution, adversely impacting litigators' financial health. While it can take years to reach a settlement or secure a judgment, the additional months required for lien resolution create compounding cash flow challenges that extend far beyond simple inconvenience. Medical lien resolution delays create several significant financial challenges:
Strategic Approaches to Lien Management
The Strategic Solution: Post-Settlement/Judgment Funding
Post-settlement/judgment funding can provide the liquidity law firms need to manage cash flows during extended lien resolution periods. This financing approach recognizes that the most valuable assets law firms hold—their receivables or rights to future legal fees from settlements and judgments—are typically not recognized as collateral by traditional lenders.
Post-settlement/judgment funding solves liquidity issues by providing necessary capital against future receivables. This approach offers several critical advantages:
Conclusion
Lien resolution represents a critical component of plaintiff side law practice that requires specialized knowledge, strategic planning, and sophisticated resource management. The complexity and duration of lien resolution processes create predictable challenges that can significantly impact both client outcomes and law firm operations.
Post-settlement/judgment funding provides a practical solution that enables firms to manage these challenges effectively while maintaining operational stability and client service excellence. The key is recognizing that lien delays are not exceptional circumstances but routine aspects of practice that require strategic planning and appropriate financial tools.
Law firms that master lien resolution while utilizing strategic financing solutions position themselves for sustained success in an increasingly complex legal environment, ensuring optimal outcomes for both clients and firm operations.
-----
Roni Dersovitz is the founder and CEO of RD Legal Funding, a pioneer in providing innovative liquidity solutions for contingency law firms. To learn more about strategic options for your practice, visit www.legalfunding.com or contact us at info@legalfunding.com or (800) 565-5177.
